Handling a Medicaid Denial and the Fair Hearing Process

Katie Camann
denied with computer pointer

You’ve done everything right: crunched the numbers, set up the Medicaid Compliant Annuity (MCA), and guided the family through the application. Then, a few months later, the notice of decision comes back marked “denied.” It’s a frustrating moment, but it doesn’t have to be the end. Most denials can be resolved without setting foot in a courtroom, provided the client is genuinely eligible and you act quickly and deliberately.

Let’s discuss why denials happen, how to avoid them, how to escalate when one arrives, and how the Krause Financial team can support you along the way.

Read More: Avoiding Medicaid Penalties When Using a Medicaid Compliant Annuity

The 5 Most Common Reasons for a Medicaid Denial

  1. An incomplete application. This is the reason we see most often. Caseworkers usually reach out to the appointed representative before issuing a denial, but if that request goes unnoticed or unanswered, a denial follows. The cause is typically a breakdown in communication rather than unwillingness to provide documents: a missing email address or an unreadable phone number keeps the caseworker’s request from reaching the right person. Be sure to send every required document with the initial submission and verify that the representative’s contact details are correct and legible.
  2. The client wasn’t actually eligible. Before designing a spend-down plan, confirm that the client is 65 or older (or blind or disabled), lives in a Medicaid-approved facility, needs a high level of care, and resides in the state where benefits will be sought. Overlooking this step wastes effort and leaves a frustrated client.
  3. Excess assets. Exceeding the limit by even $1 can sink an application. Some clients hold ten or twelve checking accounts, making it easy to miss a small one, and income deposited late in the month turns into a countable asset the next month. That’s why it’s important to leave a cushion. We generally suggest targeting about $1,500 for the institutionalized individual (instead of the full $2,000 limit) and roughly $5,000 of breathing room for the community spouse.
  4. Disqualifying transfers. Medicaid examines the applicant’s transactions during the five-year lookback period, and gifts made in that window can trigger a penalty period. Each state applies a divestment penalty divisor, which approximates the average monthly cost of nursing home care. A $50,000 gift in a state with a $10,000 divisor, for instance, results in five months of ineligibility. The rule can also work in your favor, as with the Gift/MCA plan for a single person. The trouble comes from a gift no one disclosed, which surfaces only when the denial notice arrives.
  5. Caseworker error. Medicaid offices frequently deal with high turnover and limited staff, and the rules are intricate. Caseworkers can misread their own state’s rules, misinterpret the facts of a case or the terms of a planning product, or simply not recognize the strategy. In our experience this is among the leading causes of denial, and supplying additional information or documentation often fixes it. We recommend attaching a cover summary to the application that explains the strategy, the anticipated outcome, and citations to the state’s own eligibility handbook. Steering the caseworker toward the right answer at the outset is much easier than overturning a wrong one later.

Tips for Avoiding a Medicaid Denial

  • Countable assets fall below the resource limit, with a buffer
  • The application is complete and accurate, and the representative’s contact information is correct
  • All transfers within the lookback period have been disclosed
  • The client lives in a Medicaid-approved facility and meets the age or disability requirement
  • A strategy summary with citations is included with the application

Read More: Prioritizing Ethical Responsibility When Using AI in Elder Law

What to Do When a Medicaid Denial Arrives

Step 1: Read the notice closely.
Stay calm and pin down exactly what the notice says. Denials take several forms:

  • An outright denial of benefits for specific months
  • A denial for programs the client never applied for
  • Eligibility with a penalty period
  • Misattributed income or assets

Some notices point only to a broad section of the eligibility handbook and give no clear reason. If that happens to you, call the caseworker and, when necessary, ask to review the internal case file. If the notice lacks the information you need to respond, you can argue that it is deficient and insist that the missing details be provided. Put the appeal deadline on your calendar the day the notice comes in.

Step 2: Escalate in order.

  1. Speak with the caseworker. Most denials end here, as long as the client was truly eligible. The file often remains open, which lets you add to the record and clear up an error or misunderstanding.
  2. Request a supervisor review. When the caseworker is set in their position or still new to the job, a supervisor may fix the file right away.
  3. Request a fair hearing. If the agency won’t budge, this is your formal route to appeal.

The Fair Hearing Process

Mind the deadline. Depending on the state, the notice of decision typically allows 30 to 90 days to request a fair hearing, and it explains the process.

Build the brief. Hearings are fairly informal in most states, so the brief doesn’t have to be elaborate. A strong one contains:

  • A clear, well-organized summary of the facts, assets, and income
  • Every available argument. New arguments generally can’t be raised on appeal, so preserve all of them now.
  • Precise citations to statutes and the eligibility handbook
  • Relevant case law, whether binding or persuasive
  • Supporting evidence, such as copies of checks showing when the spend-down took place and financial statements
  • A list of any expert witnesses

Prepare your witnesses. Plan your questions in advance and rehearse. Keep in mind that the state can cross-examine them.

What to expect on the day. Fair hearings nearly always take place by phone. The format is informal: brief opening statements, testimony from any expert witnesses, cross-examination, and follow-up questions from the hearing officer or administrative law judge (ALJ). Since ALJs handle many kinds of benefit appeals, they may not know Medicaid planning rules well. The judge may ask for a post-hearing brief, which gives you an opportunity to provide citations you couldn’t pull up during the call.

The ruling. The ALJ generally has around 90 days after the hearing to issue a decision. When a ruling is reversed in your favor, the agency usually accepts it, although it can choose to appeal. If the ruling goes against you, you can take the case to a higher court, which is why it pays to preserve every argument.

Tips for Success

  • Find the cause right away. Many denials stem from simple misunderstandings that can be settled with the caseworker before a hearing becomes necessary.
  • Push back on a deficient notice. If it doesn’t give you enough information to respond, insist that the missing details be provided.
  • Cross-examine a stand-in witness. If the person who made the decision doesn’t appear and sends another caseworker instead, ask about their firsthand knowledge of the case and argue that their testimony deserves little weight.
  • Don’t accept the “loophole” label. Your planning methods are grounded in federal and state statutes and regulations that courts have upheld. Don’t let the agency portray them as taking advantage of a gap in the law.
  • Keep the larger stakes in mind. A single bad ruling can set poor precedent statewide and undermine planning strategies for every practitioner.

Don’t Face a Denial Alone – Fair Hearing Support from Krause Financial

Even when our products are fully compliant and lawful, denials can still occur, particularly as some states look harder at Medicaid planning than they once did. That’s when the right partner matters most.

At Krause Financial, we do more than supply products. We work alongside you from planning through approval. Our company was founded by an elder law and estate planning attorney, so we know better than any other annuity provider how important it is to be ready for a denial. That’s why we’ve built a first-rate legal team in house, with multiple attorneys and a dedicated support line. Our in-house attorneys provide hands-on help with strategy, documentation, and fair hearings, so you can advocate with confidence and help your clients secure the benefits they’ve earned.

If a client is denied in connection with a product bought through our office, reach out as soon as you can. We’ll review the facts and advise you on resolving the matter with the caseworker. If a fair hearing is needed, we’ll be with you through the whole process at no charge, offering litigation support and expert testimony on your client’s annuity.

To learn more or get started, schedule a call with us today!

Katie Camann
By Katie Camann | Senior Content Specialist

As Senior Content Specialist, Katie drafts and edits content across multiple platforms, including blogs, guides, emails, white papers, videos, brochures, website pages, and more. She conducts research and gathers up-to-date information to keep our clients well-informed.

Attorney Access

Access More In-Depth Resources

Join Attorney Access to view our entire library of white papers, case studies, and state-specific planning information.